Selecting Journal Articles
Where was the article published? Does it come from a scholarly journal published by a university press or one that is connected to an organization of researchers?
What is the author's main argument? See the accompanying abstract or skim the first page or two of the article.
What are the author's qualifications? Look at the brief biographical sketch accompanying the article or check the web. What other articles and books has the author published?
When was the article published? Are there more recent articles that may incorporate newer evidence and interpretations?
Reading Journal Articles Critically
How does the author summarize previous scholarship on the questions involved? Thinking about this will add to your understanding of the broader historical context.
What disciplinary approach/es does the author take? For example, is the article written from the point of view of history or political science? Are there interpretations from additional academic fields, like anthropology or sociology, introduced within an article that explores an historical or political question?
What makes this author's argument significant? What new ideas does this article offer?
What kinds of primary sources does the author use? What evidence does the author offer to support the argument and how does the author interpret that evidence?
What are the author's conclusions? What concluding ideas does the author draw from his or her argument? Do you find it convincing? Are there questions that were not fully answered?
The databases below allow you to search for journal articles by subject. Use the filters to focus your search results by such categories as type of publication (scholarly versus popular) or by publications years.
When you find a title of interest, if the full text is not immediately available (as in JSTOR and Proquest), use the Find It button to check for Haverford's holdings.
___________________________________________________________
Example
What are the physical and psychological effects of over-medicating patients with dementia?
Step 1: Break up this research question into two or three main concepts. Ignore extraneous words.
Step 2: Conduct an initial search with these words, and quickly scan the results.
Step 3: Using information from your initial search, add synonyms, acronyms, and variant spellings.
Databases, like the ones below, index journal articles in all subject areas, rather than concentrating on one particular field of study. This approach can be especially useful when your topic involves more than one subject. These three databases are also quite large and kept up-to-date very currently. They can often provide the material you, if you are not doing in-depth research.
Usually researchers find more sources by looking at the footnotes in an article or book, but these will always be older than the publication you have in hand. Citation indexes like the Web of Science (which includes sections for the Social Sciences, Arts and Humanities, and Science) are set up to search for sources cited in the footnotes of journal articles as soon as they become available.
This allows you to find newer articles which cite the books and articles you already know are key for your topic. By relying on connections between authors rather than subject words and by moving forward in time, citation searching can open up new avenues of research.
See this tutorial for more information on cited reference searching.
Let's say you're interested in how African American families and communities have historically approached elder care.
Using the America: History & Life database, you try the following query:
There are 71 results, so you decide to narrow the historical period to 1850-1900.
Now you find a few interesting and relevant results:
Perhaps you're curious about workhouses and similar institutions, and wondering about conditions and care for the elderly residents.
Using the ProQuest Research Library database, you try the following search:
There are only 18 results, so you decide to take out the subject term and replace with two more parentheticals:
"elder care" OR health OR condition* (all text)
History (subject)
Now you have a larger set that you can narrow according to source type, document type, and so forth. You end up with a few highly relevant articles: