Skip to Main Content

PSYC 200: Research Methods & Statistics + Lab (HC) Spring 2024

Psychology 200: Research Methods & Statistics (Lei, Carson)

Popular Literature Versus Scholarly Literature

  Popular Scholarly
Author Staff writer; journalist Expert in the field; known credentials
Audience General public Scholars, researchers
Language Little technical language or subject-specific jargon Uses technical language and subject-specific jargon
Coverage Broad topics; shallow coverage; shorter length Narrow topics; in-depth coverage; longer length
Documentation Usually no bibliography; may have links throughout Bibliography present
*Peer-reviewed? No Usually

*To tell for certain if an article is peer-reviewed, Google the journal's website. The About section, Author Guidelines, or information on the editorial process will typically tell you if articles within that journal are peer-reviewed.

Primary Literature Versus Review Literature

Scholarly literature then falls into two categories: primary literature and review literature

Primary literature (AKA primary research articles AKA empirical articles)     

  • An empirical article reports the findings of original research done by the authors of the article.
     
  • Empirical articles are usually published in peer-reviewed journals.
     
  • An empirical article poses a research question or states a hypothesis.
     
  • ​To determine whether or not you've found an empirical article, scan the article (or even just the abstract). Look for an introduction, methods, results, and discussion sections.

Review literature

  • Review articles in the sciences summarize previously reported findings rather than present new findings, often pulling together the findings of multiple empirical articles. In doing so, review literature often gives a broader view of the current state of understanding in a given topic area.

How do I find an empirical article?

  • There's no perfect way to find empirical articles. Most empirical articles will describe a study that has been done, so you're best bet is to use the word "study" as one of your search words.
     
  • Also look at the bibliographies of review articles; the authors likely used one or more primary research articles to write the review.
     
  • Some databases (e.g. PsycInfo, PubMed) have a special limit for different types of articles.​

     

Visual Representation