Skip to Main Content

Digital Literacy: Countering Bias, Misinformation and Disinformation (HC)

Digital Literacy Fall 2022

Questions to Ask

When choosing what to read, whether for the day's news or for a research paper, these are useful questions to ask yourself.

  • Author - What is the author's training and experience?  Have they published other material in this subject area?

  • Publication Platform - Where does the source appear?  Is it in an online journal or a book from a university press? Does it have a connection to a larger project?

  • Audience - Who are the intended readers?  Is it for the general public or a particular interest group?  Is the author addressing researchers and college students?

  • Discipline Focus - What subject approach does the author take?  Scientific, political, literary?  If literary, is there a special interest in a particular kind of interpretation, such as linguistic, psychoanalytic or gender theory?

  • Documentation - Are there footnotes and bibliography for further reading?  Does the author engage with ideas from other writers and researchers?

  • Date - When was the source published?  Do you need to find a more recent point-of-view?                                                                     

Popular Articles Versus Scholarly Articles

  Popular Scholarly
Author Staff writer; journalist Expert in the field; known credentials
Audience General public Scholars, researchers
Language Little technical language or subject-specific concepts Uses technical language and subject-specific concepts
Coverage

Broad topics; shallow coverage; little or no original

research; shorter length 

Narrow topics; in-depth coverage; original research; new

ideas; longer length

Documentation Usually no bibliography Bibliography present
Peer-reviewed? No

Often reviewed by scholars in the field prior to publication and 

improved by their critiques

Peer Review - How Does it Contribute to Credibility?

Faculty will often ask that you use peer-reviewed articles for your papers.  This is a process in which journal editors send submitted articles to a researcher in the specific field under discussion for an outside review.  The author's name is withheld, so that the critique and comments can be objective.  Articles are accepted for publication contingent upon revisions and recommendations from the reviewers.  This practice ensures accuracy and encourages new developments in research.

Watch this brief video to learn about the peer review process and ways to find these journal articles.