Skip to main content

Fake News

Introduction

Comet restaurant: the subject of "Pizzagate"In the weeks leading up to the 2016 US presidential election, you’ll likely remember encountering stories about the Pope endorsing Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton selling weapons to ISIS. Fake news stories like these are not new, but in the post-print social media age, the potential for misleading information to go viral is.

This topic guide will provide you with tools, strategies, and additional resources to help you cultivate informed skepticism about the information you encounter on the Internet, and shield yourself from the dangers of consuming and sharing dubious or flat out incorrect information.

By DOCLVHUGO (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

What Kinds of Fake News Exist?

The term "fake news" is applied to many different forms of false information. Here a few categories and examples of viral fake news:*

Fake News Websites

Fake, false, or regularly misleading websites that are shared on Facebook and social media; some of these websites may rely on “outrage” by using distorted headlines and decontextualized or dubious information in order to generate likes, shares, and profits

Examples:

Fake news headline reads, "FBI Agent Suspected in Hillary Email Leaks Found Dead in Apparent Murder-Suicide"

Hoax Websites

Websites presenting deliberately fabricated falsehoods (usually on one specific topic or theme)

Examples:

Dog Island homepage claiming dogs can be send to island to live free

Propaganda Websites

Many fake news sites fall under this category, but there are also politically motivated sites that present biased reference/biographical information

Example

Homepage of martinlutherking.org with links to fake biographical information

Born Digital Images

Digitally manipulated images often shared on social media, which are typically intended to prank a gullible audience

Examples:

Fake photo of the Statue of Liberty with waves crashing in a storm

Satirical Websites

Satire/comedy sites which can offer important critical commentary on politics and society, but have the potential to be shared as actual/literal news

Examples:

Satirical headline reads, "Your Move, Netflix: Hulu Just Secured The Exclusive Rights to Stream Helen Mirren's Death"

*Adapted from the four broad categories of fake news, according to media professor Melissa Zimdars of Merrimack College

Evaluating News Sources

Anyone can publish anything on the Internet. Therefore, it's important to critically examine the information you encounter, especially on social media. The following list of criteria is not comprehensive, but can help you spot fake or misleading information.

undefined

Authorship: Can I identify the author? Does s/he have the credentials to write accurately on the subject?

undefined

Bias: Was the article published by a partisan organization or written to provoke an emotional response?
Currency: Does the publication date affect the accuracy of the source? Claims are often disproved over time.
Sources: Are there other sources that confirm that article's claims? Does the article refer to an original source? Am I able to find that source and judge it for myself?
Design: Does the website look as if it were designed by a professional or an amateur? Is it heavily ad-laden? Are there spelling and grammar mistakes?
Domain: Does the website have an unusual URL? Site names that end in "lo" like "Newslo" are often fake. URLs like ".com.co" can be fake version of the real one.

Fact Checking

There are several sources you can consult to fact-check claims on dubious websites and social media:

Remember that you also have access to a wealth of reliable sources through the library. Statistics and results from scientific studies are sometimes spun when reported in popular sources, so cut out the middleman and find the original source through the library's many subscription resources and recommended data sources.

Talking About Fake News

The recent rise of viral fake news is a complex phenomenon that is part of a larger media literacy and sociopolitical crisis. This glossary of key terms can help you navigate challenging conversations around the issue.

confirmation bias

The tendency to believe information is credible if it conforms to the reader’s/viewer’s existing belief system, or not credible if it does not conform

container collapse

Trouble discerning the original information container, format or information type–blog, book, pamphlet, government document, chapter, magazine, newspaper, journal, or section of the newspaper or magazine or journal–once publishing cues are removed and every source looks like a digital page or a printout.

 
content farm/mill

A company that employs a staff of freelance writers to create content designed to satisfy search engine retrieval algorithms with the goal of attracting views and advertising revenue.

 
echo chamber

“In news media an echo chamber is a metaphorical description of a situation in which information, ideas, or beliefs are amplified or reinforced by transmission and repetition inside an “enclosed” system, where different or competing views are censored, disallowed, or otherwise underrepresented.” –Wikipedia

fact checking

The act of verifying assertions either prior to publication or after dissemination of the content

filter bubble

When search tools present with the stories we are likely to click on or share based on our past activity, potentially affirming our biases, we need may be experiencing what Eli Pariser calls a filter bubble.

herding phenomenon

As more journalists begin to cover a story, even more journalists are likely to join the herd, imitating the angle the story initially took rather than developing alternate or original approaches or angles.

native advertising

Paid, sponsored content designed to look like the legitimate content produced by the media outlet

satisficing

A portmanteau of the words satisfy and suffice introduced by Herbert Simon in 1956 to refer to the tendency of people, bounded by time limitations, to select good enough information over optimal information

triangulation or cross verification

Researchers establish validity by using several research methods and by analyzing and examining multiple perspectives and sources in the hope that diverse viewpoints will can shed greater light on a topic.

virality

The rapid circulation of media from one user to another.  When we forward sensational stories, often from social media without checking their credibility in other sources, we increase their virality.

Source: http://blogs.slj.com/neverendingsearch/2016/11/26/truth-truthiness-triangulation-and-the-librarian-way-a-news-literacy-toolkit-for-a-post-truth-world/

Bibliography

Select reports, blog posts, and popular articles containing additional information on fake news and Americans' media consumption: